Why Relying on One Lead Source Could Cost Your Business Big-Time
by Devon Osborne
Read it to me! Click the video below.
Running a service area business is no easy task. The competition is fierce, and the digital space is constantly evolving. Many business owners are tempted to focus on one lead generation method—whether it’s Local Services Ads (LSA), Pay-Per-Click Google Ads, or organic search (SEO). But here’s the deal: putting all your resources into just one channel is like betting your entire savings on one horse in a race. Sure, it might pay off once in a while, but more often than not, it leaves you scrambling when things don’t go as planned.
The best strategy? A balanced approach that leverages all three: LSA, Google Ads, and organic search.
The Risks of Relying on One Channel
Each channel has its strengths and limitations. Imagine depending solely on Google Ads for leads. It’s great when your ads are performing well, but what happens when the cost per lead spikes, or your ads get suspended? You’re left with nothing. This isn’t just speculation—it’s a common scenario. By focusing on only one, you leave your business vulnerable to the unpredictability of digital marketing.
-
LSA: While LSAs connect you with high-intent customers in your local area, you’re limited by location, competition, and Google’s algorithms. One bad review or a competitor with a higher budget can push you out of sight.
-
Google Ads: These are fantastic for instant visibility, but rising click costs can quickly drain your budget. Worse yet, if your ads aren’t converting, you could be throwing money down the drain.
-
Organic Search: This offers long-term results, but SEO takes time and patience. Plus, you’re at the mercy of Google’s frequent algorithm updates. A drop in rankings can send your traffic—and leads—plummeting.
Why Diversification Wins Every Time
A smart business owner knows that each method works best when paired with the others. A balanced strategy ensures that when one lead source falters, the others pick up the slack. Here’s how you can make the most of each channel:
-
LSA for Immediate Results: If you want leads fast, LSAs are gold. They allow your business to show up at the top of search results with a “Google Screened” badge, boosting credibility. Plus, the pay-per-lead model means you only pay when a potential customer reaches out.
-
Google Ads for Customization and Reach: Whether you want to run ads in a particular region or promote seasonal services, you can dial in your campaigns to fit your needs. And while paid ads might seem expensive, a well-optimized campaign can still bring in a consistent stream of leads.
-
Organic Search for Long-Term Growth: Organic SEO is the marathon, not the sprint. It may take time, but the rewards are lasting. By regularly optimizing your website and Google Business Profile (GBP), you can build credibility and trust over time. This is especially valuable because organic leads are often seen as more authentic compared to paid ones.
The Results Speak for Themselves
Let’s take a look at a real-life example. An electrical contractor in Colorado faced an issue with high lead costs— over $250 per lead versus a target of $140. By focusing not only on Google Ads but also investing in LSA and organic SEO, they managed to spread the risk. When their paid ads weren’t converting, leads from LSAs and organic traffic kept their business moving. Their decision to diversify also allowed them to run a successful database reactivation campaign, generating 44 opportunities from past leads. By balancing their approach, they avoided the trap of relying too heavily on one source.
Take the Long View
Success in digital marketing isn’t about quick wins—it’s about long-term stability. Diversifying your lead sources with Local Services Ads, Pay-Per-Click Google Ads, and organic search (SEO) ensures that your business won’t crumble when one strategy falls short. You’ll have multiple streams of leads, giving you the flexibility and resilience to adapt to market changes. If you want to grow your business sustainably, it’s time to stop gambling on a single channel. Balance your strategy, and you’ll not only survive but thrive.
